Ordinary acrylic paint need to do, and after that seal it with mod podge or other paint sealers to prevent it from chipping. Decorate with rope or yarn. It's possible you are searhing for a far more rustic try to find your pencil holder. If that's the case, use http://polarprodjiphantom4lensco75318.blogdon.net/the-greatest-guide-to-designer-pen-holder-for-desk-12342260